Author |
Message |
|
I am having major problems doing compute work with this 378.49 driver (the first R378 driver), released today!
It won't work at all for me! Details below.
Can you please test, then reply with your results?
- Do you have the same problems?
- What GPU? Maybe it's Maxwell-specific?
- The more results the better!
I'll be using DDU, then installing 376.60 (the last R375 driver), fresh, so I can keep crunching, available here:
http://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/4293
Thanks,
Jacob
--------------------------------
GPUGrid tasks will repeatedly say the following, until the task stops trying resulting in error:
1/24/2017 8:30:01 PM | GPUGRID | Task e4s8_e3s14p0f83-ADRIA_FOLD_crystal_ss_contacts_20_ntl9_1-0-1-RND3321_0 exited with zero status but no 'finished' file
1/24/2017 8:30:01 PM | GPUGRID | If this happens repeatedly you may need to reset the project.
--------------------------------
PrimeGrid OpenCL Genefer, will immediately crash.
If I run:
primegrid_genefer_3_3_0_3.12_windows_intelx86__OCLcudaGFNWR.exe -q "43322502^131072+1" -d 0
It will immediately crash, with the following error:
Error: OpenCL error detected: CL_OUT_OF_RESOURCES.
--------------------------------
i7-5960X CPU, 64 GB Ram
Windows 10 x64, Version 1607, Build 14393.693
GTX 980 Ti (2 in system - EVGA GTX 980 Ti FTW, Dell GTX 980 Ti Reference)
378.49 Drivers |
|
|
|
Wicked. I have 2 systems, and I'm getting different results.
- Could this problem be specific to the GTX 980 Ti?
- Could it be specific to how much RAM is installed? :)
System where both GPUs fail to compute at all:
i7-5960X CPU, 64 GB Ram
Windows 10 x64, Version 1607, Build 14393.693
GTX 980 Ti (2 in system - EVGA GTX 980 Ti FTW, Dell GTX 980 Ti Reference)
378.49 Drivers
System where all GPUs compute just fine:
i7-965XE, 12 GB Ram
Windows 10 x64, Version 1607, Build 14393.693
EVGA GTX 970 FTW, EVGA GTX 660 Ti FTW, MSI GTX 660 Ti OC
378.49 Drivers |
|
|
|
I've repro'd the problem, using just 1 GTX 980 Ti, and just 16 GB RAM.
I suspect that this driver has completely hosed compute on any GTX 980 Ti.
Can anyone help test to confirm? |
|
|
|
Note:
The new 378.49 setting for "Optimize for Compute Performance", is a factor.
When set to ON, I'm able to crunch on my GTX 980 Ti. When set to OFF, I'm unable to crunch on it. Since I sometimes game on this PC, I'm going to revert back to 376.60 drivers.
====================================
378.49-nvidia-control-panel-quick-start-guide.pdf
... says:
Feature: Optimize for Compute Performance
Values: Off (Default), On
Notes:
Windows 10, Maxwell GPUs and later.
Offers significant improvement for some Compute applications. Care should be taken when turning this setting ON, as there can be unpredictable effects with some applications and graphics features.
====================================
The following article:
http://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/4370
... says:
This setting is intended to provide additional performance to non-gaming applications that use large CUDA address spaces and large amounts of GPU memory when run on graphics cards based on second-generation Maxwell GPUs. Graphics cards based on other architectures do not utilize this setting. |
|
|
|
Today's 378.66, does NOT fix the compute problems with the GTX 980 Ti GPU. Compute is still broken by default, for GTX 980 Ti on: 378.49, 378.57, 378.66. It's possible that GTX 980 GPUs are also affected.
NVIDIA suspects that the next R378 driver may have a fix.
I'm still using 376.60, that last known R375 driver, as a workaround for my PC that has GTX 980 Ti GPUs.
Regards,
Jacob |
|
|
|
I believe GTX 980 GPUs may also be affected.
So, if you have a GTX 980 or a GTX 980 Ti, stick with 376.60, until R378 is working properly :) |
|
|
|
The issue has been fixed.
The 378.72 hotfix driver, released today, contains the fix.
Announcement: https://forums.geforce.com/default/topic/994534/geforce-drivers/announcing-geforce-hotfix-driver-378-72/
Hotfix page: http://nvidia.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/4405
Also, I now believe it was specific to GTX 980 Ti GPUs only, and did not affect GTX 980.
Hurray - I can use R378 now :) |
|
|
Steve DoddSend message
Joined: 26 Dec 08 Posts: 17 Credit: 2,892,112,729 RAC: 17,795,350 Level
Scientific publications
|
Jacob,
Thank you for all your hard work identifying/tracking/to closure this issue. Although it didn't affect me directly, I still appreciate someone willing to help with issues of this type. Good job!
____________
|
|
|
|
Thanks Steve! :)
My main rig consists of 2 GTX 980 Ti GPUs, so ... I had a good reason to hound NVIDIA. And I actually am now respected by their QA guys, for my work on this bug and previous ones. I even gained a friend.
Fun fun. I'm just happy to be using R378 without issue finally! |
|
|
|
there is new driver out => 378.78
he works now
|
|
|
an0nSend message
Joined: 21 Mar 16 Posts: 1 Credit: 365,257,422 RAC: 0 Level
Scientific publications
|
I'm running 2X 980 SC cards on Driver 378.78. Installed this driver on March.10.
Since that date, a large chunk of tasks have started either "Exiting with zero status but no finished file" or telling me the output file is absent.
I don't believe this issue is fixed. I also have "Optimize for computation performance" enabled. |
|
|
|
If you turn "Optimize for computation performance" OFF, then restart ... does that fix the issue?
"Optimize for computation performance" is known to have some issues, and I don't trust it yet. Try to see if turning it off and restarting, helps you. |
|
|
Erich56Send message
Joined: 1 Jan 15 Posts: 1120 Credit: 8,939,970,176 RAC: 31,722,188 Level
Scientific publications
|
If you turn "Optimize for computation performance" OFF, then restart ... does that fix the issue?
"Optimize for computation performance" is known to have some issues, and I don't trust it yet. Try to see if turning it off and restarting, helps you.
Jakob, could you please tell me where I can find this setting.
Maybe this has to do with the problems I am experiencing with my GTX750ti and my GTX970, both running on Windows 10 with relatively new drivers.
(more details hereto I had posted in the "Graphic Cards" thread).
|
|
|
|
"Optimize for Compute Performance" is a new setting, in "Manage 3D settings", in the NVIDIA Control Panel. It is applicable to Maxwell or later, in Windows 10, per the "NVIDIA Control Panel Quick Start Guide" that is downloadable for each driver. It likely doesn't show if you don't have a Maxwell-or-later GPU in a Windows 10 system.
The "NVIDIA Control Panel Quick Start Guide" says:
Feature: Optimize for Compute Performance
Values: Off (Default), On
Notes: Windows 10, Maxwell GPUs and later. Offers significant improvement for some compute applications. Care should be taken when turning this setting ON, as there can be unpredictable effects with some applications and graphics features.
The UI says:
This setting allows you to significantly improve performance of some compute applications. Note that this setting may have a negative impact on some graphics features such as Sparse Texture.
Typical usage scenarios:
- Select On for higher potential performance in compute applications.
- Select Off when graphics features like Sparse Texture are used.
The first R378 driver, 378.49, had a problem where GTX 980 Ti GPUs would fail all computation, unless the user specifically turned this feature to ON. Subsequent drivers, starting with the 378.72 hotfix driver, have fixed that issue, such that I can leave it at Off, since I don't want any risk of gaming problems or problems in other applications.
That is the full summary of the feature, the bug in this post, and the drivers that broke/fixed it. |
|
|